It happened this past Tuesday night. I was playing an evening gig at a restaurant/tavern in nearby Winston-Salem. It was a small crowd - it was a Tuesday night, after all - but there was one guy who sat right in front of me the entire night. He had his back to me, facing the bar, but there he sat until 10:00, when I wrapped up my set and began packing up.
He turned to me and said, "Nice job there. Enjoyed it." I thanked him.
He continued: "Do you mind if I offer some constructive criticism?"
It's pretty rare, but every now and then I get something like this. I'd say maybe five times out of 100. Usually it's something along the lines of song selection or "you-should-really-play-at-such-and-such-place," etc. I really don't mind hearing about ways I can improve what I do, so I told him sure.
He began. "Well, first off, your guitar playing was fantastic. I could listen to you play guitar all night. But your vocals..." He paused for a moment, as if to think about exactly how he wanted to put it. "Your vocals, they just aren't there."
Huh. I said okay and asked him what specifically about the vocals "wasn't there." Was it my pitch or my tone, or something else?"
He responded, "Oh no, those things were fine. I just don't think you're meant to be a singer, that's all.
Let me intervene here for a second and say that I've never considered myself a first-rate vocalist. Sure, I sang in my high school's show choir, as I chronicled in this post. Sure, I've had voice lessons where I learned all about control and singing from your diaphragm and not your throat. I know how to prepare my voice before I sing, and I know how to take care of my voice, which is part of the reason I'm not coaching swimming anymore (too much yelling). But I'll never be mistaken, in my opinion, for being one with a truly great, marketable voice. I know this.
Still, I consider myself a fairly decent singer. In fact, of the two I think I sing better than I play guitar. I know the types and styles of songs that work well with my voice. I think I have a good range. So to be told that my vocals "just weren't there" - well, that was a new one.
I was gracious - the tip jar was was still out there, you see - so I thanked him for his thoughts and went back to my packing. I figured that'd be the end of it.
I was wrong.
Because apparently this guy wasn't sure I got the point. He continued: "I hope you don't mind me saying, man. Like I said, you're a guitar virtuoso. Your guitar playing is great. Just not so much the voice." He thought for a second. "You know what you'd be great at? You'd be great at playing lead guitar in a band and singing backup. Yeah, that'd be it, right there. Your voice is perfect for not being heard as much."
Ouch.
Be gracious, Steve, be gracious. I didn't tell him that I play keys and sing mostly backup in a band called Mediocre Bad Guys. I didn't see the point. So again, I nodded my head and thanked him for his thoughts.
He wasn't done.
"I mean, it's not like everybody can be good at everything, right? One out of two ain't bad."
Wow.
"Besides, like I said, your guitar playing - amazing. I could listen to you play guitar all night."
Now he was repeating himself.
Which anyway, let's talk about that guitar playing, shall we? If there's one thing I've never mistaken myself for, it's some stellar guitar player. And that's easy in general for guitar players to do. You get someone playing a few chords, maybe learning the "Stairway to Heaven" lick, and they suddenly feel like they're the next Jimmy Page. If they're smart they eventually come back to earth and realize they are barely scratching the surface. In fact, that's the secret of a successful musician, I think - it's not just being good at your instrument, but knowing your limits on it too.
This happens with even seriously good guitar players. Take the movie It Might Get Loud that came out last year. Three renowned guitarists: U2's The Edge, Jack White of White Stripes fame, and the aforementioned Page. They came together with their guitars and pedals and amps and such, ready to collaborate. All three were mutually respectful of the others and seemed genuinely interested in the sharing process. But when Page ripped off the opening guitar riff of "Whole Lotta Love," the faces of Jack White and The Edge said it all. They looked like kids in a candy store, smiles of awe and wonder slowly spreading across their faces, realizing they were in the presence of true guitar greatness that existed on a planet other than their own. Good guitarists know their limits.
I know my limits. I know I am a pretty good guitar player that was born to play rhythm and in no way was ever intended to play lead. I've tried, and it's not pretty. I know I play in a band of three guitar players (including me when I'm not playing keys), and that I'm third best. And you know what? I'm fine with that.
So how this guy could see me as some stellar guitarist after listening to me for two and a half hours, I have no idea.
Back to the conversation. I was getting kind of tired of him repeating himself, so I thought I'd try to change it a bit. In a way that I hope came across as genuine and not accusatory, I asked if he played any instruments himself. Well, he was coming across as the expert. "Oh no, no no no. I have no musical talent whatsoever."
I see.
I asked him what he did for a living. He was in town on business, he said; a New Yorker wondering why mid-town North Carolina didn't have a night life to 2am every night. He kept talking. He said work was kind of rough for him "because our government isn't worth a *#@%#."
You can see where this conversation went.
I was all packed up now. He offered to help me take stuff to the car. For the first time ever I would've been perfectly happy not having any help. Even so, we carried stuff to the car. I thanked him for his help, he told me no problem. We shook hands and turned our separate ways.
"Like I said, man, keep up the guitar playing! Just find someone else to sing for ya. You'll be alright if you just keep up the music!"
I certainly will.
Recent Comments